Kevin Gilbride needs to go... he is the Tim Lewis of offensive coordinators!

By GM Be Nasty
Special to Bleeding Sports

The main reason why the Giants have pre-maturely exited the 2008 playoffs is because of the pathetic play calling of Kevin Gilbride. Here is a man who has watched Eli Manning for years and still doesn't understand the man CANNOT throw the ball into the wind. Gilbride refuses to acknowledge this fact and instead of utilizing the run he goes to the passing game time and time again. Just look at the Sunday night game against the Redskins last year when Eli threw the ball 52 times and the Giants lost to a team that was quarterbacked by Todd Collins.

You would think Gilbride would learn after he was thoroughly lambasted for that game plan, but unfortunately for Giants fans he didn't learn his lesson. In that same year he wanted to throw the ball all over the field in the rain, wind, and snow at Buffalo until he was bailed out by two long runs by Jacobs and Bradshaw. And then this year against the Eagles not once but twice Gilbride tried to get cute with his play calling. In week 14 against the Eagles he pulls the Mario Manningham reverse out of his hat to stall a drive in plus territory and continuely called for long passes from his quarterback.

Now on to yesterday's debacle:

Eli's first pass should have showed his bone headed coach that he was not able to control the ball on long passes especially to the outside. But no, he refused to pay attention AGAIN. Backed up on their own 13 yard line up by 3 Gilbride calls a play action two person passing route that calls for his immobile quarterback to roll out and throw a deep out to Hixon in the teeth of the wind that resulted in an INT returned to the Giants two yard line. The game plan heading into this drive should have been to chew up as much time as possible so the Eagles would not have the benefit of the wind any longer.

Now we come to 1st and 5 at the Eagles 21 with 1:55 left in the first half. The Eagles are on their heels and the Giants have moved the ball down field by running up the middle, but Gilbride channeling his inner Mike Martz decides this is the time to get innovative and comes out with 3 straight passing plays out of the shotgun formation. All the Giants had to do was run the ball once to get the clock going and Philadelphia would not have seen the ball again until the second half. Because of his putrid play calling he gave the Eagles the chance to score points at the end of the half and the possibility of them doubling up because they got the ball first in the second half.

Finally lets move to the 4th quarter with the Giants down 9 points and needing to score twice to win the game. The Giants get the ball with 14:56 left and Gilbride calls for 5 straight running plays which ended with Eli Manning's girlie attempt at a QB sneak on 4th and inches. The defense then holds the Eagles to a punt and the Giants get the ball back at the 11 yard line with 10:22 left in the game and down by 9. At this point I can only hold my breath thinking about what the genius will come up with on this drive and Gilbride doesn't fail to impress. The passing guru has now become conservative and calls for runs on 6 out of the next 7 plays ending with Jacbos being stuffed on 4th and 2 which sealed the Giants postseason fate.

So to recap. On the two most pivotal drives of the game when the Giants needed to score and save clock Gilbride decides to ball play control. The only explanation for this disgusting coaching performance is that Gilbride must have looked up at the scoreboard and thought that the Giants were winning 23-11.

I am sick and tired of this man and his indefensible moves. He hinders the Giants ability to win every week and these factors are magnified without the abilities of Plaxico Burress to bail out FlutterLI Manning on his deep throws.